In Silence, Remembering
ἔγω δὲ φίλημμ᾽ ἀβροσύναν [...]
τοῦτο καί μοι
τὸ λάμπρον ἔρως ἀελίω καὶ τὸ κάλον λέλογχε [1]
There is, as I fallibly feel and understand it, nothing more now for
me to do, save live reclusive in silence, remembering, heedful of
hope of human change and of the beautiful numinosity of a personal
love, of life itself; a beauty so often known by us yet so often
obscured or profaned or destroyed by our selfishness, our hubris,
and the suffering we thus cause and inflict when we forget or scorn
or are unaware of ourselves as but one fragile error-prone,
microcosmic and affecting, connexion to all Life who but briefly
exists on one planet orbiting one star in one galaxy in a cosmos of
billions of such star-filled galaxies.
No more, thus, are there articles, essays, or missives, for me to
write; no more replies, in answer to queries, to be sent by modern
communication means or even via fountain pen lightly impressed upon
paper. Indeed, there is no more contact with others; no more
interference in the lives of others, no more presumptive knowing.
Enough said and written; far too much; with much - most -
valureless, rejected, disowned:
"Writings disowned are everything - apart from some
poetry and my Greek translations - written before 2002; everything
written about National-Socialism, politics, 'folk culture', and
Islam before 2010; everything - with only a few exceptions -
written about The Numinous Way before 2011; and several items
about The Numinous Way written since 2011."
For the stark and uneasy truth is
"...that I have no real, no definitive, answers for
anyone, including myself. All I have now is a definite uncertitude
of knowing, and certain feelings, some intuitions, some
reflexions, a few certainly fallible suggestions arising mostly
from reflexions concerning that, my lamentable, past, and thus -
perhaps - just a scent, just a scent, of some understanding
concerning some-things, perfumed as this understanding is with
ineffable sadness." [2]
Thus all I now really, personally, feel may (just may) - of my
multitudinous decades-long, effusions - communicate something of
some small and worthwhile interest are my Recuyle of
Pathei-Mathos, the compilations De Novo Caelo et Nova
Terra and Pathei-Mathos - A Path To Humility, and the
few poems in the collection Relict. Some few thousand words
from, perhaps, a quarter million, or more.
There is also no need nor
desire, within, for me (as some others in recent years have
suggested) to "get involved with social change" (or to "go out into
the world and try to give something back") since there is, as I
wrote in reply to a personal correspondent last month [3], the
reality, the knowing, of me
having made, and knowing and feeling I made, so many
mistakes, shown such poor judgement, been so arrogant, so selfish,
for so many decades - for most of my adult life. Given this
reality, I simply do not trust myself anymore not to cause
suffering, not to make even more mistakes, not to show poor
judgement again. Just as I know my responsibility, my blame, for
those my past mistakes and their human consequences.
Thus, why would I want to inflict myself on the world anymore?
External engagement might in theory (just might) be possible for
me again were I to have the guidance, the oversight, of others; a
moral authoritative framework provided by good people I could
empathize with and trust to guide, advise, correct me. But even
then, even then given my past propensity to be hubriatic and
selfish, I might veer away from doing what was right.
For the simple honest truth is that I now feel, in my very being,
that I have no right to, can find no justification for me to -
beyond that necessitated by personal honour in the immediacy of
the moment - interfere in the lives of others, in however small a
way even if my initial motives might be (or seemed to me to be)
good. For who I am to judge, decide, things beyond the purvue of
empathy and a very personal honour? I am just one fallible
exceedingly error-prone human being with a long proven history of
impersonal interference, of hubriatic, suffering-causing, and
selfish, deeds. Someone who does not trust himself anymore and who
values and tries to cultivate wu-wei. Which is the major reason
why some months ago I ceased to write (to pontificate) - about
anything; leaving me with only some few and sporadic, and soon
also to cease [4], personal correspondences such as
this.
In effect, I feel I am not - by being reclusive - retreating from
the world, just seeking not to inflict my error-prone self on the
world, on others. An error-prone self, a person, I admit I now do
not like very much. Which is why there is also no longer any
desire, not even any secret desire, to share my life, in however
small or complete a way, with anyone or even with others be they
friends old or new. Of course I could be wrong, and am just being
silly or stupid. But it is how I have come to feel.
All I now have therefore are the brief human contacts that this
type of reclusive non-religious life allows or finds is fitting.
The smile, the cheery return of a 'hello' or a 'good morning' when
a person is passed while out walking. Or perchance talk of the
weather. No reason for me to be gruff, aloof or rude. Quite the
contrary - a need to smile; to be polite; perhaps even a little
charming and briefly. As if such small so human things so briefly
made might be some minuscule emanation of that wordless quiet
quite inexplicable inner joy and peace which somehow in some
strange manner seems to flow within when I am out, outdoors,
wherever whenever, able thus to feel the freshness of the air, see
clouds and sky, feel this living planet as Nature lives and
changes, and be again one particular if fragile brief mortal
emanation, one microcosmic none-harming connexion, to all Life.
For there, alive, it is as if I am who and what I now should be:
no thought, no words, to spoil or soil earth, wind, sky, sea,
clouds, heavens, or water.
But yes, there is a certain inner emptiness, and often, and
bearing grief and sadness, when alone indoors. Inner vacant
sometimes colding spaces which perhaps a belief in God - or the
gods - might fill, and which certainly a partner or prayer or both
would warm and dissipate. Yet this certain inner emptiness, such
sadness, I sense is perhaps is as it should be for me, as part
expiation for the varied harm my varied pasts - in this one life -
have caused.
So many, so very many many, others in so many places world-wide
far less fortunate than I, so that I have to - must - accept my
pottering hopefully now non-harmful way of life, remembering.
Always remembering that θάνατος δὲ τότ᾽ ἔσσεται, ὁππότε κεν δὴ
Μοῖραι ἐπικλώσωσ᾽ and the
suffering I personally have caused, balanced (perhaps) as such
remembering is by a (perhaps naive) hope that someone or some many
may learn and change as I seemed to have learnt and changed:
learned to see, to feel, to try to gently be, the goodness we
humans are capable of and have often shown ourselves to be capable
of. A goodness revealed by empathy, and thus presenting to us an
understanding of innocence, peace, forgiveness, honour, love and
joy, far beyond any words I know.
The
grievous reprehensible sadness-causing mistake I as extremist,
with my fanatical hubriatic certitude of knowing, made for some
forty years - and which all extremists of whatever kind always
make - was/is to place some idea, some ideal, some dogma, some
abstraction, before the innocence of human beings and before those
quite simple things which empathy and pathei-mathos reveal and
which express our humanity:
"...the desire for personal love and the need to be
loyally loved; the need for a family and the bonds of love
within a family that lead to the desire to protect, care for,
work for, and if necessary defend one's loved ones. The desire
for a certain security and stability and peace, manifest in a
home, in sufficiency of food, in playfulness, in friends, in
tolerance, in a lack of danger. The need for the dignity, the
self-respect, that work, that giving love and being loved,
provide..."
and a knowing of, a feeling for, and acknowledgement of,
innocence: where those who are personally unknown to us are
unjudged by us and are given the benefit of the doubt, since this
presumption of innocence of others – until or unless direct
personal experience, and individual and empathic knowing of them,
proves otherwise – is the fair, the reasoned, the numinous, the
human, thing to do.
That reprehensible mistake I made is why extremists embody and
manifest hate and violence and conflict; because extremists
dehumanize, as well as so often enjoying and needing the
exhilaration, the sense of identity, the 'enemies', that hate and
violence and conflict and abstractions give birth to and always
thereafter nurture. A dehumanization so evident in the truth that
extremists place some goal, some idea, some ideal, some dogma,
some abstraction, some political/social/religious agenda, before a
personal love, before a personal loyalty, before stability, peace,
and innocence; blind as extremists mostly are - willfully or
neglectfully, or naturally because of their character - to the
good and to the good people of human intentions which and who
exist and which and who have existed in those societies such
extremists almost invariably, because of their hubriatic
certitude-of-knowing, seek to undermine, destabilize, decimate,
overturn, revolutionize, or destroy.
But I have no chanted, sung, or contemplative Opus Dei to try, in
monastic peace and with hope and faith, to balance - Soli Deo
Honor et Gloria - the unwise deeds of so many; nor any longer a
desire or need to interfere in the lives of others. So there is
for me only the living of each moment as it passes: no aim, no
goal. Instead:
The smile of joy when Sun of Summer
Presents again this Paradise of Earth
For I am only tears, falling
David Myatt
December 2012
[1]
I love delicate softness:
For me, love has brought the brightness
And the beauty of the Sun ….
Sappho, poetic fragment: P. Oxyrhynchus. XV (1922) nr. 1787 fr. 1 et
2
[2] Pathei-Mathos – Genesis of My Unknowing, May 2012
[3] My Error-Prone Self, November 2012
[4] And now - December 2012 - ceased.